Elephant Ethics

Once again we are reminded of the many shades of grey we face regularly in the zoo and aquarium industry as a decision on the future of elephants at the LA Zoo was handed down from the CA Superior Court last week.

The suit, brought against the zoo by a well-meaning real estate agent, Aaron Leider, demanded that elephants be banned from the zoo and relocated to a sanctuary.  Judge John Segal ultimately ruled that elephants may remain at the zoo, but the zoo must essentially clean up its act, stating, among other things, that the zoo must ban negative re-enforcement tools, such as bull hooks and electroshock.  However, the zoo discontinued use of these tools years ago.

The judge’s 56-page decision berated the zoo, essentially pointing out inadequacies of captivity and lack of understanding of how captivity affects the elephants.  He writes: “The Elephants of Asia exhibit at the Los Angeles Zoo is not a happy place for elephants.”

Aside from the obvious question (who is this judge to assert whether or not an elephant is happy?) the lawsuit brings up questions with which we are often faced—and are rarely brave enough to answer.  Is captivity ever good enough?  Should animals only be in the wild?  How much interaction with humans should captive animals have?


Photo by LA Times

To me, there are no perfect answers.  But, we need to remind ourselves that the zoo industry is constantly evolving—an evolution that is sometimes slow, but on the whole clearly visible.  As we continue to understand the needs and psychologies of animals, both in and out of captivity—as any scientist worth his or her salt will tell you, they are different!—captive environments and lifestyles will change.  Nothing in life is completely static.

I am not afraid of these confrontations, of these questions, of these indignations.  They push us to examine.  They push us to improve.  And maybe one day we will no longer have the need for zoos and aquariums, but at the rate we as a species are destroying habitat, captive environments may be the only sanctuaries left.

2 thoughts on “Elephant Ethics

  1. Yes, Zoo elephant exhibits are evolving, and often benefitting elephants. But, the LA Zoo has completely missed that mark. It spent all of its massive budget on visual deception for the paying public, squandering the opportunity to do something special for its elephants. The undisputed evidence at the recent trial proved that its elephants are being mistreated in numerous ways, causing them pain, suffering and premature death. The judge documented these facts, but few affiliated with the Zoo industry are willing to listen. As always, they ignore the needs of the elephants, focusing instead on justifying, excusing, diffusing and confusing. The facts have been chronicled. Why not accept the facts and do something to help the elephants? How many elephants have to die, prematurely and in pain until Zoos will pay attention to

    their suffering.?

  2. As a spectator at the trial, I found the plaintiffs evidence presented was overwhelming. Elephants do not belong in captivity in small spaces like zoo’s provide. They suffer like no other animal. Twenty three zoos in North America have voluntarily closed or are in the process of closing their elephant exhibits. It’s time that zoo’s start evolving and paying more attention to the welfare of their elephants.. We can’t continue with outdated care of these majestic mammals. We know too much. I would suggest anyone in the zoo and aquarium industry read the transcripts from the Los Angeles Zoo trial. It makes it clear how much the elephants suffer. It will give them a new appreciation for these self aware creatures, as it did for me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s